麥芽糖醇是安全的糖替代品嗎?

Basic knowledge of maltitol

Maltitol is a carbohydrate called a sugar alcohol or polyol, which is a water-soluble compound that occurs naturally in many fruits and vegetables. Maltitol is made from starch rich in maltose, a disaccharide composed of two glucose molecules. It is used in foods such as baked goods, chewing gum, sugar-free chocolate, chocolate coatings, hard candies and ice cream to provide a rich, sweet and creamy texture.

ice cream

Safety of maltitol

The safety of maltitol has been reviewed and confirmed by health authorities around the world, including the World Health Organization, the European Union, Australia, Canada and other countries. The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has also declared maltitol and maltitol syrup eligible for use.

Pay attention to the place

Maltitol is considered a safe alternative to sugar, but diabetics should remember that it is a carbohydrate. This means it still has a glycemic index. While not as high as sugar, it still has an impact on blood sugar. It's important to note that your body doesn't absorb as much sugar alcohol as sugar. Compared to sucrose and glucose, maltitol is not completely digested, resulting in a slower rise in blood sugar and insulin levels. Therefore, it can still be used as an effective alternative for diabetics. Just monitor intake and read labels.

glycemic index

While the safety of maltitol (and other sugar alcohols) is well-documented, some sugar alcohols (such as mannitol and sorbitol) can cause gastrointestinal discomfort, including gas, bloating, and diarrhea if consumed in excess. Therefore, packaged foods containing mannitol or sorbitol must carry a warning on their labels about potential laxative effects. Maltitol has been shown to be well tolerated at commonly used doses and does not require warnings on products containing it. There are no other significant health concerns with using maltitol or other sugar alcohols.

Some sugar alcohols can cause gastrointestinal upset, including gas, bloating, and diarrhea.

Maltitol and health

Maltitol gives you a sweetness close to sugar, but with fewer calories. Therefore it helps in weight loss. It has no unpleasant taste. This can help you stick to a low-calorie diet if you want to lose weight or manage diabetes. Maltitol and other sugar alcohols also do not cause cavities or tooth decay the way sugar and other sweeteners do.

Oral health

Sugar alcohols have been shown to benefit oral health in a variety of ways. When we eat foods containing maltitol, the bacteria in our mouth begin to metabolize it, although this process is incomplete because we lack the necessary enzymes. Therefore, oral bacteria produce much less acid (10-30% less) than sugar. Therefore, maltitol is considered non-cariogenic (i.e., "tooth-friendly") because the acids produced by maltitol metabolism do not cause enamel erosion or cavity formation.

The act of chewing also protects teeth from cavity-causing bacteria by promoting saliva flow. This increased salivation and other non-cariogenic properties (e.g., sweet and cooling taste) are why sugar alcohols such as maltitol, mannitol, sorbitol, and xylitol are used in sugar-free chewing gum. Because of these properties, the FDA recognizes maltitol and other sugar alcohols as beneficial to oral health.

Blood sugar

Like other sugar alcohols (except erythritol), maltitol contains calories in the form of carbohydrates. Maltitol is slowly and incompletely metabolized in the small intestine to equal amounts of glucose and sorbitol. Glucose is easily absorbed in the small intestine, and sorbitol continues into the large intestine, where it is fermented by microorganisms in the gut. Therefore, the consumption of maltitol (compared to the same amount of sugar) requires less insulin secretion, which helps keep blood sugar levels lower.

Recommended intake

Maltitol is not an important part of a balanced diet. Because sorbitol is the result of the digestion of maltitol, consuming too much maltitol at one time may cause gastrointestinal upset. But these effects may not be the same for everyone. Consumption of foods containing 30 g of maltitol was well tolerated by most people, with mild gastrointestinal effects observed at 40 g of maltitol. Consuming large amounts of maltitol may have a laxative effect.
For those following the low fermentable oligosaccharide disaccharide monosaccharides and polyols (FODMAP) diet, since maltitol is a polyol, food sources of maltitol need to be monitored.

Maltitol alternatives

Maltitol and sugar alcohols are commonly used as ingredients. They are usually not used alone. So if you're experiencing bloating and stomach aches due to maltitol, there are some simple alternatives you can use in your cooking and baking. These alternatives can still help when you need to limit your sugar intake to lose weight or have diabetes.

Stevia

Stevia is considered an emerging sweetener because it is a combination of other types of sweeteners. Stevia plants grow in South America. It is 200 to 300 times sweeter than sugar and contains no calories. Compared to sugar and other sweeteners, stevia does contain some nutrients, including:

  • Potassium
  • Zinc
  • Magnesium
  • Vitamin B3

The stevia plant is also a source of fiber and iron. Currently, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has approved only refined stevia.

Erythritol

This is also a sugar alcohol. However, unlike maltitol, it has no glycemic index and has fewer calories. It also doesn't usually cause stomach pain or bloating. Since it's still a sugar alcohol, it doesn't have the unpleasant taste of artificial sweeteners.

Agave and other natural sweeteners

Agave nectar is considered a natural sweetener, but it can still be processed to some extent. It is one of the highest sources of refined fructose—not just table sugar. Table sugar contains about 50% refined fructose. Refined fructose consumption is associated with:

  • Obesity
  • Fatty liver
  • Diabetes

Honey, maple syrup, and molasses are also natural sweeteners. They all contain varying amounts of refined fructose. Most of them, including honey, are very similar to sugar, including their calorie content. They should be used primarily for their taste, not to save calories.

Artificial sweeteners

Artificial sweeteners are manufactured and are usually much sweeter than sugar. They are a very low- or no-calorie alternative to sugar, making them ideal for dieters. They also generally don't affect blood sugar levels, which makes them beneficial for people with diabetes. However, recent research suggests that these sweeteners have effects on gut bacteria that can indirectly affect insulin sensitivity and blood sugar levels over time. While some artificial sweeteners include warning labels indicating that they may negatively affect your health, most health agencies agree that there is not enough research to support this. They are FDA approved and safe for consumption.

Conclusion

Many people are trying to reduce their sugar intake due to reasons such as weight loss and diabetes. Maltitol and other sugar alcohols may be suitable substitutes. However, if you have diabetes, be sure to discuss consuming maltitol-containing foods with your healthcare provider and nutritionist. They will be able to determine if it is the best sugar substitute for you. They can also help you determine the optimal amount to help you avoid unpleasant side effects. It's best to know and read labels. Don't assume that when a product says sugar-free it means it's calorie-free. Depending on the type of sweetener used, it may still contain calories and a glycemic index, which can affect your weight loss goals or health conditions like diabetes.

Related Products

Review

All comments are moderated before being published

HealthyPIG Magazine

View all
死亡氣味 :科學如何理解生命最後的氣息

死亡氣味 :科學如何理解生命最後的氣息

人類死亡後,身體嘅代謝同細胞運作會急劇改變,隨住時間推進,組織開始分解,產生一系列特有嘅氣味化合物。呢種 死亡氣味 (Odor of Death) 唔單止係動物可以嗅到,亦成為法醫學 (Forensic Science) 研究嘅重要領域。甚至有人提出,狗可能能夠嗅到人「臨終前」嘅早期氣味改變。

狗隻能否嗅出疾病甚至死亡?——從嗅覺科學到臨床研究

狗隻能否嗅出疾病甚至死亡?——從嗅覺科學到臨床研究

人類同狗相處幾千年,唔少人都曾經觀察到:狗似乎「知道」主人唔舒服,甚至有人報告狗會喺主人臨終前出現異常行為。呢啲現象令科學家開始研究:狗隻係咪真係可以嗅出疾病,甚至察覺死亡徵兆?

答案係:狗確實能透過超強嗅覺 (Olfaction) 偵測身體嘅代謝變化,從癌症、糖尿病,到感染性疾病。但關於「臨終氣味」嘅研究仍然有限,更多係臨床觀察。

幻覺:大腦點樣自己製造「假影像」

幻覺:大腦點樣自己製造「假影像」

幻覺 (Hallucinations) 並唔係靈異現象,而係一種 大腦自我製造影像或感覺 嘅過程。當冇外界刺激存在,但大腦卻產生「真實感受」時,就叫幻覺。研究指出,幻覺源於 大腦訊號錯亂神經傳導物質失衡,甚至同 睡眠失調 有密切關係。

心理學上的「預知錯覺」:點解我哋以為自己可以預測未來?

心理學上的「預知錯覺」:點解我哋以為自己可以預測未來?

好多時候,我哋都會有種感覺:「咦!我早就預測到會發生!」,甚至覺得自己擁有「第六感」。但從心理學角度睇,呢種「預知」其實並唔係超能力,而係 大腦嘅認知偏差 (Cognitive Biases)記憶錯亂 (Memory Errors) 造成。以下三個心理現象,最常被誤以為係「預知未來」

大腦嘅「預測功能」:點解我哋係一部預測機器

大腦嘅「預測功能」:點解我哋係一部預測機器

科學研究一直證實,所謂「超自然預知 (Precognition)」並冇可靠證據。但人類大腦本身卻具備一種極強嘅 預測功能 (Predictive Function)。從神經科學角度嚟睇,大腦其實係一部 Prediction Machine(預測機器),不停利用以往經驗去推測未來,再根據新收到嘅感官訊號作出修正。呢種能力解釋咗點解人類可以快速反應、避開危險,甚至提升學習同決策效率。

遲起身唔等於懶!夜貓同雲雀原來係基因決定

遲起身唔等於懶!夜貓同雲雀原來係基因決定

有啲人天生 早睡早起,朝早 6 點自然醒身,精神奕奕;但亦有人喺夜晚最有活力,凌晨兩三點先想瞓。呢種差異唔係單純習慣問題,而係與 Chronotype(睡眠型態) 有關。Chronotype 由基因 (Genetics)、年齡 (Age)、生活環境 (Environment) 一齊決定,直接影響你嘅睡眠時間、精神狀態同工作效率。

腦淋巴系統:大腦喺瞓覺時點樣「清垃圾」

腦淋巴系統:大腦喺瞓覺時點樣「清垃圾」

我哋成日聽人講「瞓覺可以休息大腦」,但其實睡眠唔單止係休息,仲係大腦清理廢物嘅關鍵時刻。近年神經科學發現咗一個重要嘅系統:Glymphatic System(腦淋巴系統),負責喺瞓覺時清除代謝廢物,包括同 阿茲海默症 (Alzheimer’s disease) 有關嘅 β-amyloid(β-類澱粉蛋白)。

睡眠不足與情緒健康:焦慮與抑鬱的隱藏推手

睡眠不足與情緒健康:焦慮與抑鬱的隱藏推手

好多香港人、台灣人甚至全球都市人,都認為「捱夜」只係令身體攰啲,但其實 睡眠不足對情緒健康影響極深。研究顯示,缺乏睡眠唔單止會令人心情差,仲係 焦慮 (Anxiety)抑鬱 (Depression) 嘅高危因素。對於 嗜睡症 (Narcolepsy) 患者,呢種風險更高,因為佢哋天生嘅睡眠結構失調,令情緒波動更加嚴重。

為何過度疲勞會令你進入「恐懼模式 」?

為何過度疲勞會令你進入「恐懼模式 」?

好多時候,大家經歷過捱夜、返工返學壓力大,會覺得整個人進入咗一種「生存模式 (Survival Mode)」:神經繃緊、疑神疑鬼、甚至有啲恐懼感。呢種情況唔只係心理作用,其實背後有大腦與荷爾蒙嘅科學解釋。