紅酒與白葡萄酒:哪個更健康?

What is wine?

Wine is made from fermented grape juice. The grapes are picked, crushed and put into barrels or vats for fermentation. The fermentation process converts the natural sugars in the grape juice into alcohol. Fermentation can occur naturally, but sometimes winemakers add yeast to help control the process. The crushed grapes are passed through a press to remove the skins and other sediment. Whether this step occurs before or after fermentation, and the color of the grapes, determines whether the wine becomes red or white. To make white wine, grapes are pressed before fermentation. Red wine is usually pressed after fermentation. After this step, the wine is aged in stainless steel or oak barrels until it is ready for bottling.

Red wine vs. white wine: Which is healthier?

What is the difference between red wine and white wine?

The main difference between white and red wine is the color of the grapes used. It is also related to whether the grape juice is fermented with grape skins. To make white wine, the grapes are pressed and the skins, seeds, and stems removed before fermentation.

To make red wine, however, the crushed red grapes are transferred directly to vats and fermented along with the skins, seeds, and stems. Grape skins give wine its pigment, as well as many of the unique healthy compounds found in red wine. Due to the maceration of grape skins, red wine is particularly rich in plant compounds found in grape skins, such as tannins and resveratrol. White wine also contains some of these healthy plant compounds, but usually in much lower amounts. Many different grape varieties are used to produce wine, including Pinot Gris, Syrah, and Cabernet Sauvignon.

Red grape varieties are used to make red wine, while white wine can actually be made from red or white grapes. For example, traditional French Champagne is made from red Pinot Noir grapes.

Wine is produced in many countries. Some of the major wine-producing regions are located in France, Italy, Spain, Chile, South Africa, Australia, and California in the United States.

While most regions grow multiple grape varieties, some places are known for one or two grape varieties, such as Napa Valley Chardonnay, Spanish Tempranillo, and South African Chenin Blanc.

Nutritional comparison

The nutritional content of red wine and white wine is very similar.

However, look at the nutritional content per 5 oz (148 ml) glass and you'll notice some differences:

Red wine Liquor
Calories 125 121
Carbohydrates 4 grams 4 grams
Sugar 1 gram 1 gram
Manganese 10% of RDI 9% of RDI
Potassium 5% of RDI 3% of RDI
Magnesium 4% of RDI 4% of RDI
Vitamin B6 4% of RDI 4% of RDI
Iron 4% of RDI 2% of RDI
Riboflavin 3% of RDI 1% of RDI
Phosphorus 3% of RDI 3% of RDI
Niacin 2% of RDI 1% of RDI
Calcium, vitamin K, zinc 1% of RDI 1% of RDI

Overall, red wine has a slight advantage over white wine because it contains more vitamins and minerals. Still, white wine contains fewer calories.

Benefits of red wine

Because it is fermented with grape skins and seeds, red wine is rich in plant compounds that provide a variety of health benefits.

It may help reduce the risk of heart disease

Red wine is the secret behind the French paradox. Such is the notion that heart disease is relatively rare in France, despite a tradition of eating a diet high in saturated fat. Research has found that drinking red wine may have a protective effect on the cardiovascular system. In fact, it's been linked to a 30 percent lower risk of dying from heart disease. Part of the reason may be because wine contains compounds with antioxidant and anti-inflammatory effects. These help reduce the risk of heart disease.

It may help increase "good" HDL cholesterol

Red wine has also been shown to increase levels of "good" HDL cholesterol, which has been linked to lower rates of heart disease. One small study found that adults who drank 1-2 glasses of red wine per day for four weeks experienced an 11-16% increase in HDL levels compared to those who drank only water or water and grape extract.

It may slow brain decline

Several studies show that drinking red wine can help slow age-related mental decline. This may be due in part to the antioxidant and anti-inflammatory activity of resveratrol, an antioxidant-like compound found in red wine. Resveratrol appears to prevent the formation of protein particles called beta-amyloid. These beta-amyloid proteins play a key role in the formation of plaques in the brain, a hallmark of Alzheimer's disease.

Other benefits of resveratrol

white wine

Resveratrol has been extensively studied for its potential benefits as a supplement. In these concentrated doses, resveratrol appears to have the following benefits:

  • Relieves joint pain: It prevents cartilage damage.
  • Helps treat diabetes: It increases insulin sensitivity. In animal studies, resveratrol may prevent complications of diabetes.
  • Extends the lifespan of various organisms: It does this by activating genes that protect against the diseases of aging.
  • May help treat cancer: Resveratrol’s potential to prevent and treat cancer has been widely studied, but with mixed results.

Other possible health benefits of wine

Many studies focus specifically on red wine, but white wine and other types of alcohol are also associated with health benefits.

Here are some of the main ones:

  • Reduced risk of heart disease:More than 100 studies show that moderate drinking can reduce the risk of heart disease by 25-40%.
  • Lower risk of death from heart disease or stroke: In a Danish study, people who drank low to moderate amounts of wine died from a heart attack or stroke compared with people who drank beer or other spirits. less likely.
  • Better cholesterol levels: Moderate amounts of alcohol also appear to improve cholesterol levels.
  • Reduced risk of death: Many population studies show that drinkers have a lower risk of death from various causes, including heart disease.
  • Reduced risk of neurodegenerative diseases: Light to moderate drinkers are less likely to develop neurodegenerative diseases such as Alzheimer's than non-drinkers and Parkinson's disease) are also lower.
  • Lower risk of osteoarthritis: At least one study found that wine drinkers have a lower risk of developing the disease than beer drinkers.
  • Reduced risk of certain cancers: Observational studies suggest that drinkers may have a lower chance of developing lung cancer.

That being said, it's important to remember that these studies are observational in nature. They do not prove causation and should be taken with a grain of salt.

Disadvantages of drinking

The biggest disadvantage of drinking wine is drinking too much. How much is too much depends on who you ask, as guidelines for low-risk drinking vary from country to country. The World Health Organization (WHO) recommends no more than two standard cups a day, five days a week. Many individual countries, including the United States, recommend limiting alcohol to less than two drinks per day for men and less than 1 drink per day for women. Some countries have even lower caps. A standard drink is defined as a 5-ounce (148 ml) glass of wine with 12% alcohol by volume. Note that many "big" red wines, such as those from California, typically have higher alcohol content, in the 13-15% volume range. The health benefits of red wine can easily be offset by drinking too much. Overdose can cause organ damage, dependence, and brain damage. Drinking too much alcohol may also increase your risk of contracting infectious diseases because it may weaken your immune system. Additionally, drinking alcohol appears to increase the risk of several cancers. These serious risks are the main reasons why health experts urge people not to start drinking alcohol for health reasons.

Is red wine healthier than white wine?

If you're going to drink wine, it's clear that red wine is healthier -- or less bad -- than white wine. In other words, when it comes to health effects, red wine is the clear winner. That being said, drinking too much alcohol should never be promoted as a way to improve your health, given the huge harmful effects that drinking too much can have. Additionally, most studies showing benefits are observational in nature, meaning they cannot prove cause and effect. If you do enjoy drinking, red wine is a better choice, but limiting your drinking (or avoiding it altogether) is always the safest option. Resveratrol has been extensively studied for its potential benefits as a supplement. In these concentrated doses, resveratrol appears to have the following benefits:

  • Relieves joint pain: It prevents cartilage damage.
  • Helps treat diabetes: It increases insulin sensitivity. In animal studies, resveratrol may prevent complications of diabetes.
  • Extends the lifespan of various organisms: It does this by activating genes that protect against the diseases of aging.
  • May help treat cancer: Resveratrol’s potential to prevent and treat cancer has been widely studied, but with mixed results.

Review

All comments are moderated before being published

HealthyPIG Magazine

View all
小朋友叫唔應?可能唔係無禮貌,而係科學:專注時真係聽唔到你

小朋友叫唔應?可能唔係無禮貌,而係科學:專注時真係聽唔到你

小朋友一睇YouTube、打機、畫畫,突然叫佢,佢完全聽唔到。係咪扮聾?係咪發展遲緩?抑或專注力問題? 研究顯示,大部分情況完全正常,與腦部的「選擇性注意力(Selective Attention)」同「過度專注(Hyperfocus)」有關,不代表有疾病。 什麼是「選擇性注意力」?(Sele...
高血壓|隱形殺手的成因、統計數據與科學研究

高血壓|隱形殺手的成因、統計數據與科學研究

  高血壓|隱形殺手的成因、統計數據與科學研究 快速導讀 高血壓係全球最普遍、但最容易被忽視嘅慢性病之一。 超過一半患者完全無症狀,但長期會破壞血管、增加中風同心臟病風險。 主要成因包括:高鹽、肥胖、缺乏運動、低鉀、飲酒、睡眠窒息症、壓力、吸煙、腎病等。 全球研究顯示:高鹽攝取加上肥胖...
為何肺癌早期大多沒有症狀?科學原理、風險因素與早期發現方法全解析

為何肺癌早期大多沒有症狀?科學原理、風險因素與早期發現方法全解析

肺癌一直是全球最常見、死亡率最高的癌症之一。令人憂心的是,大部分肺癌患者在早期(第一、二期)都沒有明顯症狀,往往直到腫瘤擴散、壓迫周邊結構或影響呼吸功能後才被發現。本文以科學角度深入講解:為何肺癌早期「靜悄悄」、身體不察覺?身體內部究竟發生了甚麼? 亦會加入實際的自我檢查策略與醫學建議。 一...
黑眼圈成因全解析:從生理、生活習慣到醫學對策

黑眼圈成因全解析:從生理、生活習慣到醫學對策

前言:為何黑眼圈總是揮之不去? 「黑眼圈」係現代人嘅常見問題之一。無論係通宵工作、壓力過大、過敏,甚至遺傳因素,都可能令眼底皮膚變黑或出現陰影。雖然多數情況屬於美容問題,但有時亦可能反映身體狀況,例如貧血、睡眠質素差、血液循環不良等 [1]。  一、黑眼圈的主要類型與成因 色素型黑眼圈(Pi...
智慧手錶 vs 專用 O₂Ring 血氧儀:血氧監測能力的科學比較

智慧手錶 vs 專用 O₂Ring 血氧儀:血氧監測能力的科學比較

1. 前言 血氧飽和度(SpO₂)是評估呼吸、循環系統狀態的重要指標。近年來,市面上兩大類可穿戴設備用於血氧監測: 智慧手錶(如 Samsung Watch、Apple Watch) 專用血氧監測設備(如 O₂Ring、指夾式脈搏血氧儀) 兩種設備的設計目的、測量方式、準確性、監測...
血氧飽和度、氧氣下降與「警戒線」的科學探討

血氧飽和度、氧氣下降與「警戒線」的科學探討

1. 前言 血氧飽和度(SpO₂)即血液中氧合血紅蛋白佔總血紅蛋白的百分比,是臨床及居家監測呼吸、循環功能的重要指標。當血氧飽和度下降,可能反映體內氧的供應或運送出現問題(低氧血症、hypoxemia)或更廣泛的組織缺氧(hypoxia)[1][2]。本文旨在探討: 血氧飽和度正常範圍與變...
冰敷(Cold Therapy)真正作用全面解析:止痛、減腫,還是幫助修復?|科學視角 + 實證文獻

冰敷(Cold Therapy)真正作用全面解析:止痛、減腫,還是幫助修復?|科學視角 + 實證文獻

冰敷(Ice Pack / Cold Therapy / Cryotherapy)係好多運動、急性受傷(如扭傷、撞擊、肌肉拉傷)時的第一時間處理方法。但不少人會疑惑: 「冰敷純粹止痛,定係真係會幫助組織修復?」「冰敷幾耐?冰敷幾多日?會唔會影響身體自然修復?」 本文從科學、醫學、運動治療角度,...
長時間保持同一姿勢後關節痛、僵硬、郁唔到:成因、科學解釋與改善方法

長時間保持同一姿勢後關節痛、僵硬、郁唔到:成因、科學解釋與改善方法

前言:為何「坐耐、蹲耐、跪耐」之後會痛? 無論係坐喺電腦前、跪低執嘢、長時間翹腳、側睡又唔郁——好多人體驗過一樣情況: 「一動就痛、一企起身腳軟、膝蓋直唔到、關節卡卡聲,又或者要行幾步先鬆返。」 其實呢種情況係非常普遍,而且通常並非關節已經壞死,而係 和關節生理、滑液循環、血液供應、肌肉張力 ...
魚醒味的科學:成因、風險與處理方法全面解析

魚醒味的科學:成因、風險與處理方法全面解析

「魚醒味」是華人烹飪文化中常見的說法,用以描述魚類在 解凍、切片或加熱後所突然出現的腥味、血水味或脂肪味。此現象並不代表食材變壞,但背後牽涉到蛋白質變化、脂肪氧化與揮發性化合物釋放等多種科學機制。本文將以科學角度剖析魚醒味的成因,並提供實證方法降低這種味道,同時探討其安全性。 🧪 什麼是「魚...